Thursday, 9 February 2023

 

Hilda’s Book of Beasts and Spirits 

By Emily Hibbs

Artwork by Jason Chan P.L and Sapo Lendario

Blog Tour Day 12



 I’ve always been a fan of companion guides/illustrated guides (is that the name for them?)  – books that are choc-full of extra information and detail about a particular topic you’re interested in.

Growing up as a devoted Stars Wars (and still am), I’ve seen my fair share of these types of books, with varying degrees of success. My daughter is obsessed with The Dragon Prince, and has an illustrated guide for that, which she keeps dipping back into. And these things got me thinking – what is the recipe for success for a good illustrated guide?

I asked my daughter and she said, ‘I just love finding more stuff out about it, it’s really exciting.’

Can’t argue with that.

My views are:

1.     It needs to be purposeful – it needs to add to what the reader already knows, especially with a few golden nuggets of information that will blow the reader’s mind

2.     It also needs to be aware that its job is not just for established fans – there is an opportunity here to entice and create new readers and new fans, so it needs to be accessible.

And guess what? Hilda’s Book of Beasts and Spirits knocks it out of the park on both my points and my daughter’s.

At this point I feel it would be a bit ironic if I then decided not to give you an explanation of Hilda and her world so here it is:

Hilda is an adventurous young girl who ‘can never sit still for long without setting off on another adventure’. She lives in the wilderness with her mother and her companion Twig ( a deerfox, more on that later!). From that starting point, all bets are off as to what she is going to encounter and creator Luke Pearson revels in the world he has created. Each adventure brings a new type of beast/monster/companion/spirit into Hilda’s world so it makes perfect sense to put them all into one place.

                                                    

 


Hilda graphic novels are short and snappy (they’re around 80 pages and aren’t text heavy), so getting the right amount of information in the guide is crucial. A good ploy they’ve used for this guide is to have notes written by Hilda on most of the pages – it adds a playful authenticity to it and ensures that there is a strong link between this, the graphic novels and the TV series. In Hilda’s first note, she mentions how she wished she’d borrowed the book from the library before she’d gone on some of her adventures – a nice aside to the on-going importance of libraries as well. Hilda’s insight also gives the reader inside knowledge – she’s lived and experienced all of this – and she revels in pointing out when the guide might not actually be 100% accurate.

The guide itself positons itself in the interesting way of being informative but also with a strong message to the reader:

‘The future of these beings depends on curious and courageous individuals who are willing to venture where none have gone before and defend those who nobody else will speak up for.’

If that isn’t a masterclass in speaking and appealing directly to children then I don’t know what is.

And so, in 6 different sections, grouped according to type of beast/spirit you can dive headfirst into the world around Trolberg. And this is where illustrated guides are great – you don’t have to read it in order if you don’t want to, you can dip into sections you’re most interested in or most intrigued by (I myself went straight for the deerfoxes in the Secretive Souls section, I just love that combination).

Each beast/spirit is given a full page illustration to introduce it, and then the information follows on the next pages, often using a range of different techniques and devices to present the information.

 


                 

The artwork is gorgeous. Really, really gorgeous. It’s done using watercolours (which I’m an absolute sucker for in graphic novels) and the results are stunning and you can really appreciate the skill involved. Hilda adds her own artwork to some of the pages as well.

 Highlights? It’s a book full of wonderful stuff but I particularly liked:

  • How to distinguish between a Marra (nightmare spirits who prey on anxious victims) and teenagers
  • The rules of Elf Poker
  • Hilda’s dream of riding a salt lion
  • Troll Translation
  • Deerfoxes – look at how beautiful they are! And the fact that the heroes of legend are all said to have had one as a companion, and that once a deerfox chooses you is your companion for life, makes Hilda and Twig’s friendship all the more special


This book is a gem - a feast for the eyes and a perfect companion to an already brilliant series. 

If you love Hilda and the world she inhabits, this is right up your street.

If you’re looking for a new series of graphic novels and TV to get into, this is right up your street.

If you like looking at seriously beautiful artwork, this is right up your street.

If you’re looking for a treasure trove of ideas on how to present a non-chronological report, this is right up your street.

I could go on and on - you get the idea. I loved this book, you'll love it too.

Wednesday, 27 July 2022

Walliams

I have read David Walliams books to my class. Not recently. But I have. 

I’m not proud of it.

I didn’t know children’s literature like I do now, and if you’re someone who is thinking of reading one to your class because they’re popular, please read on.

Since he published his first children’s book, The Boy in the Dress, in 2008, David Walliams has been a prolific children’s author:

18 stand-alone novels

9 picture books

6 short-story collections

It is estimated that his books have generated over 37 million sales worldwide.

I can’t speak for every school, but you see a lot of love for him in my school (from the children) , and I would imagine a lot, if not all of the schools of people I interact with on social media might be the same.

We don’t read them at home. My youngest daughter asked me a while ago why we didn’t have any David Walliams books and I believe my answer was something along the lines of, ‘I don’t think some of his representations of certain people are very good and there are better books out there.’

And I thought nothing of it. We didn’t need Walliams as the books we were reading were better, in my opinion.

When my eldest daughter turned 9 her friend bought her two books – Demon Dentist and The Midnight Gang, both by Walliams. There was an awkwardness – there was Walliams in our house! -  and she didn’t know what to do with them.

And that is when I realised I’d been an idiot about the whole thing. I thought back to my initial response to my youngest daughter and realised without any real explanation it was absolutely useless. I also felt bad – my eldest daughter’s friend had bought her those books because she knew my daughter loved reading. That’s thoughtful and kind and shouldn’t be ignored.

So I decided we should both read one of them, discuss it and then she can make her mind up about Walliams for herself. More than anything, Rights of the Reader no.5 states ‘The right to read anything.’

So I read Demon Dentist.

And I absolutely LOVED it!

I didn’t really.

Firstly, the premise – a boy called Alfie lives with his dad (his mum died during childbirth) who is retired due to ill health from working down a coal mine. Where they live weird things are being placed under pillows where teeth have been left. A very suspect dentist called Miss Root comes into school, then ends up taking all of Alfie’s teeth out. A social worker called Winnie starts to support the family, Alfie hatches a plan with his friend Raj, the newsagent, Miss Root turns out to be a witch, Alfie’s dad dies quite unnecessarily, Winnie and Raj get married and become Alfie’s guardians. That’s pretty much it.

There’s nothing new, interesting or imaginative about the story at all. And it’s too long.

You can call it quits there if you want in regards to Walliams, there are far better books out there.

But I don’t want to, because I want to talk about Winnie and Raj. I’m also aware of Gabz, another black character who doesn’t get the same treatment as these two, but if you’re going to defend someone by saying that they’re not always offensive with their characters, it’s not a great starting point.

Winnie is a social worker introduced on page 72. From her picture at the beginning of the book you can see that Winnie is a black woman.

Here is an extract from p.78:

‘I have heard so much about you from your father, young Alfred,’ said Winnie, spraying biscuit crumbs all over the boy and the carpet and even as far away as the curtains as she spoke. She took a large and noisy slurp of her tea from her cup, and washed the remainder of the biscuit down her throat.

So Winnie doesn’t have great manners, which is funny, right? And the slurping of the tea gets more extreme as the book goes on with lots of capital letters and exclamation marks, to make it, I guess, even more funny?

It’s not a great start, and totally unnecessary.

Oh it gets worse…

Winnie peered at the boy. She slid along the sofa, and her big fat face came close to his, like a hippopotamus inspecting a little bird that has landed on its nose. ‘Oh my word! Look at the boy’s teet!’

‘My what?’ said Alfie.

‘Teet!’

‘My teet?’ replied Alfie, confused.

‘Yes, boy…’ said the social worker in a frustrated tone. ‘YOUR TEET!’

‘I think Winnie means your teeth…’ ventured Dad.

‘Yes, that’s what I said!’ implored the lady.

‘TEET! T,E,E,T,H, TEET!’

This ‘joke’ is repeated throughout the book, mainly getting its mileage from Winnie pronouncing Mr Griffith, ‘Mr Griffit’. She is again corrected, and again she spells out the name ‘Griffith’ correctly, and then immediately pronounces it ‘Griffit’. Oh how hilarious.

I was lucky enough to be mentored by a wonderful woman from St. Lucia, so I’m well aware of the pronunciation of certain sounds people from the Caribbean may have. A bit of reading later and I found this online:

In terms of phonology, Jamaican Creole has a sound system which is independent from English. The speakers of the language do not use the “th” sound.

Winnie, in her mind, is speaking perfectly normally, and gets frustrated when people don’t understand her. But it’s played for laughs in the book.

So we’re laughing at someone for how they speak, based on where they’re from?

Hmmm.. pretty sure there’s a word for that.

Now I’ll move onto Raj, the newsagent. From his picture and name, it’s fair to say that Raj is Asian. The name Raj can be short for Rajesh, or it can be Raj on its own.

We’re into lazy stereotyping territory here, unfortunately, with an Asian shop owner. Where I grew up people referred to these shops in another way, which I will not write here. Walliams will be well aware of that term. There’s nothing wrong with owning a shop or newsagents – that’s a good job doing a good service for the community. But not in Walliams’ hands.

Here Raj is on page 218:

Indeed, when Alfie entered this particular afternoon, Raj was snoring away with a gobstopper still in his mouth. A slick of the newsagent’s spit was spreading over the newspapers. Raj woke with a start, spat out his sweet and exclaimed:

‘Ah young Alfred! My favourite customer!’

His voice was as bright and colourful as the confectionary he sold.

Alfie always looked forward to seeing Raj. The newsagent knew how poor he and his dad were, and being a kind-hearted man he would often give Alfie a treat to take home. A melted ice lolly, a chocolate bar that had been slightly nibbled by a rodent, or a bag of jelly babies that Raj had accidentally sat on so all the tiny tots were now flattened. Raj wasn’t a wealthy man, and couldn’t afford to give anything more.

Raj is kind because he gives Alfie dirty food? That’s not kind. Not at all. You can’t write something like that and put that he’s kind at the end and get away with it. Raj is a recurring character throughout the books and is often seen trying to sell out of date food. An article written by Jenn Selby in 2018 (https://inews.co.uk/culture/books/david-walliams-racism-childrens-book-character-raj-indian-shopkeeper-midnight-gang-240641) had this quote from him:

“I am not a bad man. I just use best-before dates as a very rough guide, rounding them up to the nearest decade!”

Raj is also a character run on slapstick and complete and total exaggeration. He’s overweight (like Winnie) and breaks things when he sits on them. He eats the liquorice in dib dabs and replaces them with black pens. His shop is ‘infamous in the town for being incredibly messy’.

Yet again we, the reader, are supposed to be laughing at this, like we did at Winnie, but they’re not in on the joke.

Here we have a black woman and an Asian man whose real purpose in the book is to provide comic relief, through the way they act and the way they speak. That’s not acceptable.

Representation in books has come a long way over the past few years, but as long as this garbage is being churned out and happily bought by parents and schools we’re going to keep having children growing up thinking this kind of thing is funny.

It’s not.

It’s racist.

And the next time my daughter asks me why we don’t have any of his books in the house, that will be my answer.

P.S My eldest hasn’t read it yet, she’s not bothered..

Sunday, 19 December 2021

2021 -  A Love Letter to Reading

So 2021 is the year I’ve really gone for it with my reading – when it’s actually become a cherished hobby, a constant in my life. Twitter has absolutely galvanised me in regards to books. So here is a (rather self-indulgent) celebration of reading and a heartfelt thank you to some people:

@jonnybid – the Obi-Wan Kenobi of the reading community. Incredible knowledge, incredibly generous.

@one_to_read - #BooksNearBedtime (which will hopefully come back?) was a Thursday night staple. The way Ben thinks about books and stories blows my mind. Always ready to explore comments and thoughts more deeply, which always leads to a richer experience for all. Absolutely the guy I’d want to teach my kids.

@TJGriffiths – a danger to the purse strings but what a guy to know! Brilliant book reviews a plenty. An absolute reading machine and great reviewer. 

@teacher_mr_r - #SundayMorningBookBlether was another wonderful weekly discussion I became a part of. A fountain of book knowledge. And his reviews are ace.

@PaulWat5 – read his books reviews – that’s all I’ll say. OK, I’ll say a bit more – his reviews are always utterly brilliant.  Oh, that and he introduced me to Flying Eye Books.

@i_teach_things – I’ve lost count of the non-fiction wonders I’ve bought from your recommendations. And #ShareStuffSunday continues to be the best, free, CPD on Twitter.

@KarlDuke8 – his #CurriculumBooks resource is a phenomenal piece of work. He shared it for free. FOR FREE.  Was also the catalyst for my new favourite hobby - #CharityBookHaul

@smithsmm – a mortgage extension is worth it for the books I’ve bought from his recommendations. Nobody on Earth can come close to his picture book knowledge. Utter legend.

@RuddickRichard – that padlet… and I’ll talk more about GNs later.

@ANewChapterBks – opened the Crossley family’s eyes to the amazing books that are out there. #RepresentationMatters and with the wonderful #BookBingo, the Crossley household’s reading habits have been truly transformed.

@rumena_aktar – encyclopaedic knowledge and a champion for diversity and inclusivity

So now onto the books. I’ve decided that as there are 12 months in a year, I’m going with 12 books to sum up my year of reading. Worth noting that not all of these books were released this year - I am Late to the Party Reader for a reason…

 

The game-changer


So this was the first graphic novel I read after being invited to join the #LetsTalkGraphicNovels group. It’s not my favourite, but I will always look on it fondly for the world it introduced me to. To sit back and hear @Mat_at_Brookes, @fella_jane, @RuddickRichard, @rcharlesworth, @smerchant13, @sam_creighton @emmamaddenisme and @my_red_spark discuss graphic novels is a treat and a privilege. Oh, and if you didn’t know already, GNs must have a seat at the reading table.

 

The book that will stay with my daughter and I


My favourite thing to do is to read to my children – I love it. In February this came out and I read it to my 8-year-old. She keeps going back to it – it will become THE book for her, I think. I don’t blame her – it’s phenomenal. The important questions it raises about the world we live in and how we need to protect it is matched by the perfectly written relationship between a girl and polar bear. Magical stuff.

 

The series



Graphic Novel royalty. Don’t believe me? Ask any child who’s read them and they’ll say the same. What a rich and vast world Kazu Kibuishi has created, full of memorable characters – plus he talked at one of our meetings and is the coolest guy ever! The artwork is flawless and the multiple storylines never get away from you and all serve the overarching story perfectly. Read them all, please.

 

The modern masterpiece



I’d absolutely loved A Kind of Spark and whilst discussing it with a boy in Y6 he insisted on lending me this. It’s stunning. The high concept never feels contrived because the two main characters are so brilliantly written by Elle McNicoll. Two books in and she's shown what a special talent she is. That sucker punch, though…

 

The perfect book



The premise of this book is 10/10. But how it unfolds in the hands of Phil Earle is something quite special indeed. Someone more articulate than me said on twitter something to the effect that it breaks your heart and then puts it back together. 100% agree. I've bought my Dad it for Christmas and can't wait to talk about it with him. An absolute stunner.

  

The long-Awaited sequel that didn’t disappoint


I’ve made no secret of my love for The Murderer’s Ape, and so this year we finally (finally!) got the sequel. Could Jakob Wegelius pull it off again? Yes, yes he could. As beautiful, rich and kind as the first book, though with a darker streak running through it, it was everything I’d hoped for and more.

The book every KS2 teacher needs to read to their class at some point


The absolute joy I had doing my version of what I thought The Beast sounded like was an utter privilege, as were the conversations on twitter to see what other folk based their voice on. This book is ace and holds a beautiful memory of lying on the sofa and reading it to my daughter for 4 hours straight. It’s hilarious, with a huge heart – just like its author.


The other sequel that didn’t disappoint


My daughter described this book as, ‘Tense, and a bit of a death book.’ Yep, I’d agree! How do you top the first book, which has such a brilliant character arc for our main character? Well, the level of danger is upped and the triumphs of the first book are quickly forgotten as our hero faces a threat from his past. Nail-biting stuff with SF Said absolutely at the top of his game.

The non-fiction masterpiece


I had absolutely no idea about anything to do with Bandoola until this was recommended and I bought it. 1. It’s a feast for the eyes, a beautiful book 2. The true story is a belter enhanced by William Grill’s stunning illustrations and a colour palate that is a gorgeous homage to the natural world. @PaulWat5’s review is absolutely on the money for this book – check it out.

The picture book that flawed me


We’d gone away to Wales with my wife’s family and I’d taken a few books with me, one of them being this. I read it and immediately gave it to my in-laws to read as well. We all agreed it was something quite special. The inevitability of the narrator’s situation never seems desperate, yet is it what he truly wants? I don’t know, to be honest, and that’s where the discussion starts – always the sign of a good book.  An understated gem.

 The book that makes me happy that it’s in the world



I love everything about this important book. The story is beautifully told and the illustrations are exquisite but I think I love it the most for the fact that I can read it to my children, I can recommend it to children at school and it feels like it’s been around for years – like it’s a classic fairy tale.


My Book of the Year



From the stunning opening chapter this book was relentless excitement of the highest order. The bad guys are wonderfully vile who will stop at nothing to protect their product (and in their view, society!) at the expense of an innocent, resilient young hero.  It’s breathtakingly brilliant and the perfect class read for UKS2. If you haven't read it - read it. Cannot wait for Spark.

So there we go. 2021 has been a stonker.

Bring on 2022.


Tuesday, 2 November 2021


A Month with Barrington Stoke

In the past year, here are some of the books I’ve read:



This list isn’t to show-off, if you’ve read my previous blogs you’ll know I’ve not always been a reader but it did get me thinking. These books are wonderfully varied, cover ages from 5-teens and I really enjoyed all of them.

And they’re all published by Barrington Stoke.

Eighteen months ago, if you’d have asked me about Barrington Stoke then I probably wouldn’t have had a clue who or what they were. Luckily, now I do.

So, who or what is Barrington Stoke? Let’s look at the website:

Barrington Stoke is a small, independent and award-winning children’s publisher. For over 20 years we’ve been pioneering super-readable, dyslexia-friendly fiction to help every child become a reader. From our specially designed font to the colour of our paper, accessibility is at the heart of everything we do.

It’s hard not to fall in love with them from this paragraph alone, but here’s the extra kicker – their books are consistently challenging, creative and, simply, brilliant.

I looked at what we had in school – our brilliant reading lead (@AmieC53) has created a reading spine where every class reads a Barrington Stoke in Autumn 1 -  and my own (ever-growing) TBR pile and saw that I had more than enough to spend the whole month reading lots of Barrington Stoke books.

So I did.

And here’s how it went.

Week 1 – Seven Ghosts by Chris Priestley, Sterling and the Canary by Andy Stanton and illustrated by Ross Collins, Keeper by Alan Gibbons and illustrated by Chris Chalik, Grandpa Bert and the Ghost Snatchers by Malorie Blackman and illustrated by Melanie Demmer 


Seven Ghosts is a cracking read. The ghost stories get creepier and subtle hints are given as to where the story is going. Twists abound and this would be a knockout read on a Y6 residential, as has been pointed out quite a few Barrington Stokes would be. I would love to see the faces on the children’s face when the final twist is revealed. A perfectly pitched ghost story for primary school.

I’d previously used Sterling and the Canary a few years ago in guided reading and remembered liking it a lot. I was right. It’s genius. It really is. The main character is hopeless and the real hero of the story has one of the best names to ever appear in children’s literature. UKS2 will be howling at this from start to finish.

Grandpa Bert and the Ghost Snatchers is a glorious read for KS1. I read most of it to a Y2 class who were near silent (enraptured) apart from laughing or enthusiastically commenting on the glorious illustrations by Melanie Demmer. A typical Little Gem – bang on the money for KS1 children and a great introduction to chapter books.

I’d come across Keeper in a Y6 class and the blurb had me hooked. I’d played a bit of football when I was younger and the character of Mick was all too familiar. What was powerful about the book was the direct effect toxic masculinity has on teenage boys and how there is no place for it. Kindness and empathy are much more powerful tools in this world and the book showcased that superbly.

Week 2 – Anna Gain and the Same Sixty Seconds by Guy Bass and illustrated by Steve May, The House of Clouds by Lisa Thompson and illustrated by Alice McKinley, The Puffin Portal by Vashti Hardy and illustrated by Natalie Smilie


Anna Gain and the Same Sixty Seconds is great fun. It’s basically Groudhog Day for LKS2. Guys Bass is one of my go-tos for this age group as his style and humour is perfect for them. Accompanied with some superb illustrations from Steve May, which perfectly capture the chaos and stress of Anna’s predicaments, this was a big slice of fun from start to finish.

I really enjoyed The House of Clouds. An intriguing set-up gets a sucker-punch halfway through and it’s another great example of Barrington Stoke books completely capturing how lost and alone children and teenagers can feel sometimes. And yet more proof that everything Lisa Thompson writes is stonking.

I’d read The Griffin Gate to my daughter and we’d both loved it. She’d since read The Puffin Portal (and again, loved it!) and she was so excited when I started reading this. Vashti Hardy takes her love of all things steampunk and has created a fabulous series centering around the Griffin family – wardens of Moreland. I love the mystery element to these stories and the clues Vashti Hardy places here and there which are perfectly pitched for LKS2 kids to play detective. Bring on The Raven Riddle.

Week 3 – Swan Song by Gill Lewis, A Dangerous Game by Malorie Blackman, Tragedy at Sea by David Long and illustrated by Stefano Tambellini, The Moonshine Dragon by Cornelia Funke and illustrated by Monica Armino


Swan Song is a wonderful book. Dylan is an angry young man, excluded from school and lost in so many ways. Going to stay with his grandpa who he has no relationship with, a swan will change his life forever. I absolutely loved this book. The character of Dylan is so perfectly written and the message of finding hope in nature is a timely reminder to us all about how beautiful and precious the natural world is.

A Dangerous Game by Malorie Blackman was the first book I’ve read with a character with sickle cell front and centre. You know something is going to go wrong - the inevitably of the boys being either mean or foolish is overwhelming -  and Malorie Blackman ramps up the tension throughout the first half of the book until, inevitably, disaster strikes but is eventually overcome when true strength is revealed. An empowering read.

Tragedy at Sea by David Long and illustrated by Stefano Tamellini blew me away. As soon as |I finished it I knew I need to read more non-fiction. This book is so accessible for KS2, especially with the full length illustrations of the ship and is an essential companion for any Titanic unit. There was so much I didn’t know about an event I’ve known about for so long. I loved how the background to the making of the Titanic set the scene for what was to come and there were so many brilliant facts such as the level of craftsmanship and opulence available on board. It truly was a fascinating insight into a time past -  the Ladies’ Writing room on board? Oh crikey…

 You really can’t beat Little Gems for KS1 reads and The Moonshine Dragon was another perfect example of this. There’s always such a great pace to Little Gems and this was no exception. An intriguing, magical premise, a cracking villain and a nice bit of human-dragon teamwork made this a really fun read. Again, the illustrations are perfectly matched to the story. I’ll be reading this to my daughter very soon and she’ll love it.

Week 4 – Monster Slayer by Brian Patten and illustrated by Chris Riddell, Ghost Stadium by Tom Palmer, The Beast of Harwood Forest by Dan Smith and illustrated by Chris King, Freeze by Chris Priestley


I realised I should have kept Seven Ghosts for the last week to coincide with Halloween but still had these 4 belters to finish the month with.

Monster Slayer by Brian Patten and illustrated by Chris Riddell was spectacular. Page after page of beautiful description would give so many opportunities for fantastic discussion and opportunities for writing and art – there could be some incredible double-page spreads created on this. It also really doesn’t scrimp on the gore, which I liked - you can’t water down Beowulf as it does it a disservice. No such problem here. And Chris Riddell's illustrations are the perfect match for the gruesome and merciless Grendel.

I absolutely loved Ghost Stadium by Tom Palmer. Genuine scares as three boys decide to camp out in an abandoned football stadium. But they’re not alone. Short chapters help to ramp up the tension - the bit outside the tent! -  and for Y6 this would be a cracking read. I wouldn’t go any lower than that, though, it really is scary. Three of us read it one day and all agreed it was superb.

The Beast of Harwood Forest by Dan Smith and illustrated by Chris King was a perfect mash-up of teenage peril and dodgy government experiments (what's not to like there?).  Right from the outset the creeps and chills build up to a very, very satisfying ending where the young trio realise what the true dangers of this world are. The Invasion of Crooked Oak will be purchased very soon!

I finished the month with Freeze by Chris Priestley and boy did it finish it in style. Another fantastic premise where our main character has a worryingly close affinity to the creepy stories being told in class. Excuse the pun but there were genuine chills in this! Your worry for main character Maya grows as each story is told until a dark history is revealed. Wonderful stuff again. I'll be checking out more of his work.

So, what do I think after reading all these?

1.     Barrington Stoke books are essential for an inclusive, exciting reading provision in schools. In every Key Stage their books will enhance any school or class library

2.     Their books are so varied, but they have a special knack of getting their young and teenage characters absolutely spot on in a variety of genres

3.     Their books are fearless – and isn’t that a wonderful trait to encourage in children?

What a month, Barrington Stoke, I cannot wait to delve deeper into your treasure troves.

Yours sincerely,

A huge fan.






Friday, 29 October 2021

Reading Scrapbooks and Brilliant Reading Leads

 

Reading Scrapbooks and Brilliant Reading Leads

In the summer of 2020 I saw a lovely post by Ceridwen Eccles (@Teacherglitter) where she had made a reading scrapbook of all the books that she had read over the summer and was going to share with her class for them to then do the same. It was stunning. At the start of the school year I saw that our reading lead (@AmieC53) had also started one over the summer. It too was stunning.

At home my two daughters were good, interested readers so I decided to start one with each of them. There wasn’t a right lot going on in Greater Manchester at the time (and Tier 3 would last for A LONG TIME!) and it became a weekly thing that we did - Saturday mornings was Reading Scrapbook Time! It’s definitely one of the best things we ever did.

I started sharing the pictures on Twitter and always received lovely feedback from authors… apart from one who never acknowledged the posts and will remain nameless (they were probably too busy with their other careers).

Oh, and for the record it wasn’t Walliams.

The scrapbooks of my daughters still remain two of the most beautiful books I’ve ever seen in my life. Yes I’m biased but I love them and love looking through them still. I got really excited about the idea of getting these into schools. I messaged Ceridwen and Jon Biddle who helped me form a group in regards to a plan about this but I’m not sure if you remember 2020-2021 but it was quite a crazy year and the (correct) decision was made to leave them until the Summer term to start. Which we did, quite a few schools got on board and it was a success.

In my own school the scrapbooks were great. There was so much interest in them and the entries were continually gorgeous and wonderful. And it was at this point I did what any respectable teacher/middle leader/subject lead/SLT would do… I analysed the data!! Get in.

We hadn’t prescribed any rules about what books the scrapbook could be done on (you can’t and please don’t) but I knew what I was going to find. We’d also asked the staff to do their own entries as well.

The Results

We did the scrapbooks from Years 2-6. On average there were about 12 entries in each one.

Here are the Top 3 most popular authors across the whole school.

In 3rd Place….. Guy Bass

I was genuinely chuffed with this. His books are ace (perfect for LKS2) and he’d done a brilliant author visit in 2020 and another brilliant virtual visit early in 2021 so they kids knew his books well. Off to a cracking start. Look at the reading culture of this school!

In 2nd Place…… David Walliams

Next!

And in 1st Place…..Roald Dahl.

What a shocker.

 

In 4th Place was Enid Blyton (boosted mainly by staff entries) and 5th was JK Rowling. Of the five JK Rowling entries, one was The Ickabog, one was Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets and the rest were simply Harry Potter with no book specified. The most popular book was Charlie and the Chocolate Factory which appeared four times across the different year groups.

This data is kind of disappointing but there were reasons to be cheerful! This was the list from a Y4 class:


And here is the list from a Y6 class:



 

You can’t argue with either of those lists in my opinion – they’re chock full of the kind of books we want children to be reading at that age. I knew that the school was moving in the right direction but there were things that needed acknowledging.

  1. Walliams and Dahl

DW popped up everywhere. It was disappointing but not surprising. We don’t push his books in our school, we don’t buy them and we don’t recommend them but they are in the class libraries though the school hasn’t purchased any of them in the last few years. I’m not into hiding books from children or putting them in the bin, that doesn’t solve anything. We just needed to make sure we were recommending better books. I like Roald Dahl, I really do, but the world of children’s literature is a far bigger place than just him.

 

 

  1. Staff needed more guidance.

The staff entries in the scrap-books looked fantastic, but the choices of books were not always very inspiring. I’m not saying that if you work in a primary school you should be a fountain of knowledge in regards to children’s literature but… no actually I kind of think you do. I can say that knowing full well that I spent years not being, and I don’t have an encyclopaedic knowledge of children’s books now but I’m pretty good. It’s made me better at my job.

  1. Lower Key Stage 2

We needed more books in this part of the school. It seemed to be the long-forgotten area and the class libraries simply didn’t have enough good books in them for the children.

Now, the good news is that whilst I was doing all this analysing, our reading lead was WAY ahead of me.

Good reading leads are worth their weight in gold in a school. Our reading lead (@AmieC53) is awesome. She lives and breathes children’s books and her classes are always surrounded by brilliant books (that’s her Y6 scrapbook list I showed earlier). She’s also developed a fantastic guided reading scheme for the school.

She decided we needed to be more prescriptive with the class readers and we needed our class reads to be as inclusive and reflective as possible. We weren’t going to showcase Black History Month, we would have inclusive, representative books throughout the year and throughout the school. The result? 5 class reads (plus a free choice) where each teacher has a choice of 3 texts based around the following areas:

Short and Sweet (all Barrington Stoke books)

Representation Matters

Reading with Empathy

Understanding Disability and Neurodiversity

Building Understanding

My eldest daughter is in Y4 and if she was at my school her teacher would have these choices:


          

We’ve also invested heavily on non-fiction in the last couple of years at our school as well. Our next project – again organised by our reading lead - is to do one of the brilliant Wishlists through A New Chapter, with a huge focus on LKS2 books and getting even more inclusive books across the school.

The scrapbooks have continued this year and again they are wonderful.

The reading culture will take time but it will happen, and I’m excited to be a part of it and support in any way I can.

 

 

Friday, 24 September 2021

 

Harry Potter and the Competitive Reading Level

 

Through conversations I’ve had as a teacher and as a parent I can say with (some) confidence that there is another Reading Tree/Book Band/Reading Level that many adults across the country subscribe to.

The Harry Potter Reading Level.


It would appear that the Harry Potter Reading Level begins at some point in Year 2 where The Philosopher’s Stone either becomes the bedtime read of choice or, even more impressively, the child starts to read it independently!

Now, I know what you’re thinking – Goblet of Fire is Greater Depth in KS1 as that wonderful exemplification from the DfE told us in 2018! But bear with me.

There seems to be a point in many a child's life when Harry Potter is introduced into their reading life and suddenly it's all about The Boy Who Lived. The further on you are with the books, the better your child is at reading.  I’ve seen parents discuss this as a teacher, I’ve seen parents discuss this as a parent and I’ve…..done it as a parent.

Child 1 is now in Y4. She loves reading and being read to and I’d wager if she was to list her favourite books that we’ve read to her over the last 18 months I reckon some definite mentions would be:

·       The Last Bear by Hannah Gold

·       The Beast and the Bethany by Jack Meggitt-Phillips

·       All 3 Starfell books By Dominque Valente

·       The Exploding Like of Scarlett Fife by Maz Evans

·       Otherland by Louie Stowell

·       A Boy Called Christmas by Matt Haig

·       Both Varjak Paw books by SF Said

·       The Griffin Gate by Vashti Hardy

Eventually, and perhaps with some prompting, I think she’d get to Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone. But it wouldn’t be at the forefront of her mind.

I read it to her in the Autumn of Year 2. I bought the Jim Kay illustrated version – stunning, by the way – and we were off! It was important to me that she loved the books before she started watching all the films. She’d watched the first two films at her cousins’ (it’s always cousins, right?) and I always said she couldn’t watch the third film as it wasn’t appropriate for her yet (don’t worry – the irony isn’t lost on me), and as Azkaban was my favourite of all the books, I was determined that she would read the book first.

Why was I so obsessed with her reading Harry Potter books?

1.     I was a Harry Potter snob who was determined that my children would love the books first and the films second. Too often as a teacher I would discuss Harry Potter and the children who were die-hard fans and had not read the books, they’d watched the films (hello DfE exemplification again!). Any Harry Potter entry into the wonderful reading scrapbooks done by the children last year was never based on a specific book, just Harry Potter in general. You can't move for Harry Potters on World Book Day.

2.     Because I’d loved the books when I'd read them all those years ago, and I still think they’re pretty good (again, Azkaban especially) and because my knowledge of books was growing but not great (see previous blog) I still kind of put the HP books on a pedestal for my children. 

And so we began. I put in a pretty good performance if I do say so myself and she enjoyed it. We finished it and I invested in some Harry Potter Lego (mainly for me to be fair).

So, the house was buzzing with Harry Potter – the first book had been read and very random Lego was being played with. Good times.

Child 1 and I started on Chamber of Secrets (again the beautifully illustrated Jim kay version) and …. we stopped reading it.

She wasn’t bothered.

And do you know why she wasn’t bothered?

Because she was (just) seven.

She was too young.

The buzz around HP was mainly being created by me. She liked playing with the Lego (probably because Lego is THE GREATEST THING EVER MADE!) but she didn’t pester me to read the books to her. That's how I know she loves a book by the way, which when you say it out loud seems really rather obvious.

I had been that parent who had fallen into the trap and getting Harry Potter books into my children’s lives far too early.

It’s easily done. Harry Potter is everywhere! And because far too many people do fall into the trap then I think there’s a danger of a pressure building up and the child or parent feeling that they have to read them.

I’m well aware there will be children out there who read them at that age who will have loved them and still do. That’s fine, but for what it is worth I’m saying this –  in my opinion Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone is an Upper Key Stage 2 book (9 years up). There are some grown-up themes that run through it (his parents have been murdered!) and I (now!) feel there are lots of other, more appropriate and better, books for children aged 6 -9. 

So yeah - my daughter is now 8 and isn't fussed on Harry Potter. And that's ok.

The Harry Potter shaped hole in my daughter's life has been filled quite easily by the astonishingly good Starfell series by Dominque Valente. If you haven’t read them then I cannot recommend them enough.  Willow Moss is the best character I’ve met in the last 18 months and every book is wonderfully original and full of magic and adventure. Child 1 was Willow Moss for World Book Day, complete with a cuddly jaguar toy as Oswin (and not a lightning scar in sight).

Have I learnt my lesson? Nah. I read Amari and the Night Brothers in a day and was so blown away by it I said we would read it to Child 1 and we did (middle of Y3). She really liked it but should have loved it – again it’s a Y5 book for me. The sequel will be coming to her in Y5.

What does the Harry Potter future bring for Child 1? Who knows? I actually spoke to her about it last night, and whether she wanted to read them again and if she felt she’d missed out.

She said, ‘Not really. There’s loads of other books I want to read instead.’

She’s a confident independent reader and they may come her way when she gets to Y5 -  I’m now adamant that she doesn’t need to read them before then and her TBR pile at the moment includes Rainbow Grey, A Dragon in the Library, An Alien in the Jam Factory, Llama Out Loud, Run Like a Girl and a few graphic novels that I’ll be passing her way.

However, there are a few characters I will be sending her way in Y5. Some I’ve deliberately not read as I want us to read them together.

Morrigan Crow and the Widdershin sisters. And I can’t wait for that...

 P.S

I didn’t buy official Harry Potter Lego, I ordered it off Wish. It was an absolute steal and when it arrived I understood why. Although it WAS Lego, there were some slight differences:

1.     It was called Justice Magician

2.     The Hogwarts Express was called ‘Wizardry Castle’

3.     It left from Platform 7 5/9